Florida gives commercial tenants five years to recover CAM overcharges under Fla. Stat. 95.11. No specific commercial CAM statute exists, so contract law and lease terms govern. Here's what tenants need to know.
Check your own documents before you keep researching.
Find My OverchargesFind overcharges in your CAM reconciliation. Most audits complete in under 5 minutes.
Find My OverchargesSee a sample report firstFlorida has no dedicated statute protecting commercial tenants in CAM disputes. There is no commercial tenant bill of rights, no mandatory audit-rights provision, and no anti-retaliation protection if you challenge your landlord's reconciliation. What Florida does have is a five-year statute of limitations for written contracts, one of the stronger CAM markets in the country, and a set of insurance-related overcharges that are endemic to the post-hurricane cost environment. If you're a commercial tenant in Miami, Orlando, Tampa, or Jacksonville, those three facts determine most of what you need to know before opening a dispute.
This guide covers the legal framework governing CAM disputes in Florida, the specific insurance premium issues that make Florida unique, and how to calculate your potential recovery window.
Florida's approach to commercial tenant CAM disputes is straightforward: the lease is the contract, contract law applies, and courts interpret it. There is no statutory overlay that grants tenants audit rights, requires landlords to maintain records, or creates a minimum dispute window. If your lease says you have 60 days from receipt of the annual reconciliation statement to object, Florida courts have consistently enforced that window. If the lease is silent on audit rights, you have a right to demand records as a party with a contractual interest in the accuracy of the charges, but no specific statutory mechanism to compel production.
The practical starting point is always the lease itself: the audit rights clause, the CAM definitions section, the exclusions exhibit, and any addenda that modified the base form.
Fla. Stat. § 95.11(2)(b) provides a five-year limitations period for actions on written contracts. Your commercial lease is a written contract. A CAM overcharge claim is a breach of that contract. This means Florida commercial tenants generally have five years from when the claim accrued to bring a legal action.
The accrual question matters. Florida courts have generally held that a contract claim accrues when the breach occurs, not when the plaintiff discovers it. For CAM disputes, the reconciliation statement is the triggering document: once the landlord delivers the statement containing the overcharge, the clock starts. The discovery rule does not automatically apply to written contract claims in Florida the way it does in some other states.
Key implication: the five-year window runs from each annual reconciliation statement, not from the date you first suspected something was wrong. A statement delivered in March 2021 has a limitation deadline of approximately March 2026.
Florida courts strictly enforce lease-defined dispute windows. If your lease requires you to object within 90 days of receiving the annual reconciliation and you wait 120 days, Florida courts have held that you may be barred from disputing that year's charges even if the five-year statutory period has not expired. The lease-defined window is a contractual condition, and Florida contract law treats conditions as binding.
This is different from California's SB 1103 framework, which creates statutory protections that operate independent of the lease. In Florida, the lease is the entirety of your protection. Read the dispute window in your lease before anything else.
Florida applies the independent covenant doctrine to commercial leases. This means your rent obligations and your landlord's obligation to accurately bill CAM are treated as independent covenants. You cannot withhold rent as leverage during a CAM dispute. If you stop paying rent while contesting CAM charges, the landlord can pursue eviction, and your CAM dispute does not constitute a legal defense to nonpayment. Disputes must be pursued through written objection, mediation (if required by lease), and litigation, not rent withholding.
Florida is one of the largest retail real estate markets in the country, with significant strip center concentration in South Florida, the I-4 corridor, and the Jacksonville metropolitan area. It also has a problem that tenants in every other state largely do not face at the same scale: hurricane windstorm insurance premiums as a CAM line item.
After Hurricane Ian in 2022, commercial property insurance premiums in southwest and central Florida increased 40 to 65 percent depending on location, building age, and carrier. The increases were not uniform, but they were broadly real. Landlords passed these increases through in full to tenants as part of the "insurance" line in annual CAM reconciliations.
Whether this passthrough is legitimate depends entirely on what the lease says about insurance.
A typical NNN lease in a strip center gives the landlord the right to pass through the cost of property insurance on the building. "Property insurance" in most standard lease forms (ICSC, AIR Commercial, and landlord-drafted forms) means standard commercial property insurance: fire, windstorm, and extended coverage. That phrasing, on its face, arguably includes hurricane windstorm coverage.
But many leases, particularly older ones executed before 2005, use narrower language: "standard fire and extended coverage insurance," "customary property insurance for similar properties," or specific exclusions of "flood, earthquake, and named storm coverage." When the lease uses that narrower language, a landlord who passes through hurricane windstorm premiums may be billing outside the permitted scope.
CAMAudit flags this under Rule 9 (Insurance Overcharge) when the insurance CAM charge includes identifiable windstorm or named-storm premium components that the lease does not explicitly authorize.
Between 2022 and 2024, Florida commercial tenants in markets with significant storm exposure saw insurance CAM line items that in some cases doubled. A tenant paying $3,000 per year in insurance CAM in 2021 might have received a reconciliation showing $5,800 or $6,400 in 2023 with no explanation beyond "increased insurance costs."
That increase is not automatically an overcharge. If the lease permits hurricane windstorm passthrough, the landlord has a contractual right to bill it even if the increase is severe. The overcharge question is whether the premium being billed is within the permitted scope of the lease, not whether the increase is large.
Consider a 3,000 SF restaurant in a Tampa strip center, signed a five-year NNN lease in 2019. The lease permits "standard property insurance" passthrough, with no explicit reference to hurricane or windstorm coverage.
Insurance CAM history:
| Year | Insurance CAM Billed | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| 2019 | $3,100 | Pre-pandemic baseline |
| 2020 | $3,300 | Normal increase |
| 2021 | $3,600 | Normal increase |
| 2022 | $4,200 | Pre-Ian, carrier market tightening |
| 2023 | $7,100 | Post-Ian windstorm premium added |
The 2023 jump from $4,200 to $7,100 represents a $2,900 single-year increase. Upon reviewing the landlord's insurance certificate and premium breakdown (requested under the lease's audit rights clause), the windstorm premium for the building was $87,000 across 28,000 SF of GLA. This tenant's pro-rata share of that windstorm component: $9,321 SF / 28,000 SF = 10.7% share of $87,000 = approximately $9,300 in windstorm premium allocated across tenants. The tenant's proportional piece: roughly $3,000 of the $7,100 total is attributable to the windstorm line.
Under Rule 9, CAMAudit flags that $3,000 as potentially excluded from the permitted scope of "standard property insurance," depending on how the lease language is interpreted.
Five-year Florida recovery calculation:
| Year | Potentially Excluded Premium |
|---|---|
| 2022 | $600 (pre-Ian windstorm component) |
| 2023 | $2,900 |
| 2024 | $3,200 (projected continuation) |
| 2025 | $3,200 |
| 2026 | $3,200 |
| Total (5 years) | $13,100 |
At the five-year SOL, this tenant's potential recovery window is approximately $13,100, assuming all years are within the statutory period and the lease language supports the challenge. The actual recoverable amount depends on negotiation, litigation, and how a Florida court interprets "standard property insurance."
| Item | Detail |
|---|---|
| Written contract SOL | 5 years (Fla. Stat. § 95.11(2)(b)) |
| Oral contract SOL | 4 years (Fla. Stat. § 95.11(3)(k)) |
| Specific commercial CAM statute | None |
| Commercial tenant anti-retaliation protection | None |
| Rent withholding during dispute | Not permitted (independent covenant doctrine) |
| Discovery rule for written contracts | Generally not applied |
| Lease-defined dispute windows | Enforceable |
The five-year SOL means you can look back across five annual reconciliation cycles. If you signed a five-year lease and never reviewed a reconciliation, you can audit every year of that lease before the first year's statement falls outside the statutory window.
The practical steps:
No. Florida has no statute specifically protecting commercial tenants in CAM disputes. Contract law and the lease terms govern entirely. The five-year statute of limitations under Fla. Stat. § 95.11(2)(b) applies to written contract claims generally, which includes CAM overcharge claims under your lease. Beyond that, Florida courts enforce whatever the lease says, including landlord-favorable dispute windows and reconciliation procedures.
Probably not. Florida courts have generally treated lease-defined dispute windows as enforceable contractual conditions. The five-year SOL sets the outer limit for a legal action, but a lease condition requiring you to object within 90 days of receiving the reconciliation statement is a separate requirement. Failing to object within 90 days may bar you from disputing that year's charges even if the statutory period is still open. Review the exact language in your lease: some windows are conditions precedent to dispute rights, while others are soft deadlines subject to equitable arguments.
Start with your lease. Most NNN and modified gross leases include an audit rights clause that gives you the right to request records upon written notice. If your lease includes this clause, send a formal written request, via certified mail, to the address specified in the notice provision. If your lease is silent on audit rights, you can still send a written demand as a party to the contract. Florida does not have a statute that compels a commercial landlord to produce records within a specific time window, unlike California's SB 1103 for qualifying tenants. If the landlord refuses to provide records, your remedies are contractual (if the lease creates the right) or through litigation discovery.
No. The size of the increase does not determine whether it is an overcharge. What matters is whether the type of insurance being passed through, including windstorm and named storm coverage, is within the scope of insurance costs your lease permits the landlord to bill. A landlord can legally pass through a 60 percent insurance increase if the lease permits that type of insurance. CAMAudit flags the discrepancy when the lease language does not clearly authorize windstorm or named storm premiums, so you can evaluate whether a challenge is warranted.
Yes. CAMAudit's Rule 9 (Insurance Overcharge) detection specifically evaluates whether the insurance charges in your CAM reconciliation are within the permitted scope under your lease. Upload your lease and reconciliation statements, and CAMAudit will flag line items where the billed insurance cost appears to exceed what the lease authorizes, including windstorm-related components that may not be covered under "standard property insurance" lease language. Pricing starts at $199 for a single audit.
CAM Recovery Guide : How commercial tenants recover CAM overcharges, with step-by-step process and state lookback windows
Insurance Overcharge in CAM: How Landlords Bill Outside the Lease
This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. CAM audit rights, statute of limitations, and dispute procedures vary by lease and jurisdiction. Consult a licensed Florida attorney for advice specific to your situation.
Upload your lease. CAMAudit runs 13 detection rules in under 5 minutes.
Find My Overcharges